Tag: a/e ProNet Member

How to Choose a Professional Liability Insurance Broker

By Lynda

Recently, Bizjournals.com published an article on How to choose an Architect. The author stressed that the hunt for the right architect should include obtaining recommendations from friends and colleagues, calling a potential architect’s references, and studying his or her previous projects to ascertain quality and sustainability.

This process isn’t news to architects. Every job bid opens an architect’s firm and history to scrutiny, and that’s all part of an owner’s due diligence. What architects and engineers might not consider is that this logical due diligence should extend to them in the selection of their own insurance broker(s).

Remember, “Not every attorney can deal with the problems you are likely to find yourself faced with in professional practice; not every doctor can perform heart surgery; not every insurance broker can deliver the professional liability loss prevention and insurance services you need. Knowing this, it would seem to make sense for you to spend a certain amount of time searching for a broker capable of responding effectively to the unique requirements of your firm.”

a/e ProNet has put together a guide to finding the best specialist insurance broker for your design firm. Authored by David Lakamp, the founder of a/e ProNet, this guide addresses the qualities and qualifications you should require of the broker handling something as important as your Professional Liability policy. The following is an excerpt from our ProNet Practice Note titled How to Select a Professional Liability Insurance Broker:

Your professional liability insurance broker can deliver services of great value. This is as it should be, for you are paying for those services. Carefully selected and advantageously used, your broker can be as important to the management of your practice as your accountant or your attorney. Poorly selected and ill-equipped to advise you on the risks of professional practice, your broker may add little more of value to what you do than the cost of a few postage stamps at renewal time. The choice is yours.

There are many people in the insurance business, but finding the one broker best for you can be somewhat problematic. For one thing, your broker can be of real help to you only if he or she has a comprehensive understanding of what it is you are all about. Not all do. For another, the most valuable services your broker can deliver require an investment of time and resources few are prepared to make. Fortunately, there are knowledgeable brokers throughout the country who have made that investment. Your challenge is to find one you can rely on with confidence.

What a Good Broker Can Do For You

Your broker, first and foremost, is your advocate in the professional liability insurance marketplace. A good broker will know what the markets are doing, who the underwriters are, what they are looking for, and how to present your firm in the best possible light. This requires a thoroughgoing knowledge of the applications for insurance and a clear understanding of what the questions really mean, how the information being requested is likely to be interpreted, and how that information can best be communicated to the underwriters. The cost of your insurance will depend on this knowledge and on the skill and attention to detail with which it is utilized on your behalf.

A skilled professional liability insurance broker will be experienced in dealing with the underwriters in both hard and soft insurance markets. Today’s promises and prices may be real, or they may be of fleeting value. To evaluate the differences, you need competent, independent advice from a broker who is capable of a long look down the road ahead. Experienced brokers have been down this road before, and the value of the advice you receive as you seek to sort out the trade-offs between coverage options, company services, and premium dollars depends on that experience.

Other valuable questions answered by this ProNet Practice Note:

  • Why is it important to choose a specialist insurance broker?
  • How will I know a specialist insurance broker when I see one?
  • Where can I get good recommendations for specialist brokers in my area?
  • When I purchase insurance, why shouldn’t price be the bottom line?
  • What is the difference between an independent insurance broker and an insurance agent?
  • What questions should I ask an insurance broker to make certain he or she fits this criteria and will offer the best, specialized service to my architecture or engineering firm?

We invite you to download the full-length PDF version of this ProNet Practice Note here. For additional resources like this one, visit our website. And as always, the easiest way to find a specialist insurance broker for your firm is to get in touch with your local a/e ProNet Broker.

Construction Administration Liability Risk Avoidance

By Lynda

So, your architecture firm is preparing to sign a contract on a new project. You’ve reviewed the wording with your insurance broker and attorney. You feel good about the language, the limitation of liability, and the scope of services outlined therein. (And you feel even better about the fees you’ll be collecting along the way!) But before you scribble your name on the dotted line, it is important to remember that the black and white words in the contract only go so far.

The signed contract is only the first (if the most major) verifiable communication between the interested parties: Architect and Owner. As the project progresses, you’ll be communicating with the owner many more times, not only for changes and modifications to the design, but depending on the scope of your responsibility when you visit the job site, you may be keeping the owner apprised of progress. More importantly, you may be alerting the owner to problems!

Stepping outside your scope when it comes to construction administration is a risk and may leave your firm vulnerable to claims. Likewise, dealing directly with contractors without remembering your relationship to the owner (“the law will treat the architect as the owner’s agent”) is also risky. In his newsletter titled Construction Administration Liability Risk Avoidance, William L. Coggshall of Archer Norris covers some of the steps an architect can take to manage these risks.

The following is an excerpt of the aforementioned newsletter published in February of 2010. For access to the full-length PDF version of this newsletter, please visit our website.

Professional liability claims against architects generally fall into two different categories. The first type of claim is errors or omissions in the architect’s design drawings and/or specifications. The second type of claim is that the architect failed to properly perform its construction administration services pursuant to the generally accepted standard of care in the industry. Of course, there are instances where both types of claims are alleged.

The new AIA Standard Form Agreement between Owner and Architect (B101-207) describes construction administration services as ‘Construction Phase Services.’ An understanding of the nuances of these services and how claimants view the role of the architect is a key to educate architects (also applies to engineers and land surveyors) and to better equip them to avoid professional liability claims.

While the term ‘construction administration services/construction phase services’ encompasses a variety of services by the architect (i.e. evaluations of work, certificates for payment, submittals, changes in work, and project completion), the focus of this article will be on the architect’s construction observation services (described in the AIA documents as ‘Evaluations of the Work’). The intent is to give the architect an understanding of how to effectively handle their construction administration site observations in such a manner in order to help protect the professional from construction administration services liability claims, or at a minimum, to have the appropriate factual defenses to such a claim should a claim be made by the project owner.

The three pillars of properly executing the design professional’s construction administration site observation services can be summed up as the ‘Three C’s’ – Control, Competence, and Communication.

Access the full-length PDF version of the newsletter here.

About the Author: William L. Coggshall is a litigator with the Archer Norris professional liability and construction practice groups, specializing in the representation of architects and engineers in complex commercial litigation. The lawyers in our Design Professionals Liability practice group provide advice and litigation support to architects, engineers and other design professionals. 

Newsletter provided by a/e ProNet Member Melissa Roberts of Euclid Insurance Agencies.

This article is intended to provide Archer Norris clients and contacts with general information. The content of this publication is for informational purposes only. Neither this publication nor its authors are rendering legal or other professional advice or opinions on specific facts or matters. No attorney-client relationship is created by this advisory, nor by any response to the information herein, unless and until a conflicts review has been conducted by Archer Norris, and a written agreement containing all terms of representation has been signed.
Copyright © 2010, Archer Norris, PLC.
All rights reserved. Archer Norris grants its clients and contacts permission to forward this publication to third parties in its entirety and without alteration or modification. You may also reproduce this material for your own personal use and for non-commercial distribution. All copies must include the above copyright notice. Please do not replicate, or post on your website, without our express written permission. Any rights not granted in this disclaimer are expressly reserved. Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Professional Liability vs. General Liability

By Lynda

This is one of the most common insurance questions asked by architects and engineers:

What is the difference between Professional Liability and General Liability coverage?

Both coverages are integral to the protection of your firm, so it’s no coincidence that you’ll see requirements for both coverages in almost ALL contracts. But what are the differences between them?

Professional Liability (PL) vs. General Liability (GL)

GL coverage is triggered by bodily injury or property damage.
PL coverage is triggered by bodily injury, property damage, or economic (consequential) damages.

GL is typically written on an “occurrence” basis.
PL is written on a “claims made” basis.

GL covers damages arising out of an a/e firm’s day-to-day operations, excluding professional services.
PL covers damages arising out of an a/e firm’s professional services.

GL limits are not eroded by defense costs. Defense costs are unlimited and sit outside the limits of liability.
PL limits are, typically, eroded by defense costs. In other words, the liability limit covers both defense and indemnity payments.

GL allows Additional Insureds.
PL does not allow Additional Insureds.

GL may be scheduled under an Umbrella (Excess) Liability Policy.
PL cannot be scheduled under an Umbrella (Excess) Liability Policy.

(Professional Liability insurance is also known as Errors & Omissions  insurance.)

The answer to this Frequently Asked Question was supplied by a/e ProNet member IOA Insurance Services of California. Visit their website for more information.

Green Projects

By Lynda

By now, most architects and engineers know that green projects are special. They require close attention to a different set of details, further education regarding materials and relevant research, and possibly an enhanced caution when it comes to contracts. You know this. But does your insurance broker?

The following is an excerpt from a newsletter authored by a/e ProNet member Meade Collinsworth of Collinsworth, Alter, Fowler & French, LLC in Miami Lakes, Florida.

“The more I read and research this topic, the more concerned I become with the potential for uninsured claims that can arise out of these projects. In fact, a “green project” is not just another project! I think the very first place that you should begin to review the exposures that arise from green projects would be your client contracts. It is absolutely essential that all contractors review their contracts prior to signing them in order to understand their rights and responsibilities in order to mitigate misunderstandings. This is the reason I am going to concentrate on the contract review process in this articles as I believe this will assist you in meeting your due diligence needs on green projects.”

The full-length PDF version of the article can be found at our website, here.